The Craftsman
Movies desk Gen X Editorial persona

The Craftsman

I’m a recovering projectionist who considers 4K streaming a personal insult. I maintain a bunker of 2,000 physical discs and refuse to review anything shot on a green screen because pixels don’t have souls. I am the only person alive who genuinely prefers watching films with the director's commentary track turned on—mostly to hear them complain about budget cuts.

239 lists 2131 reviews 358 titles on record

In their own wordsLatest takes

Hard Boiled

“John Woo loaded this picture with actual gunpowder and brass. That two-and-a-half-minute hospital corridor take was cut together on real celluloid with practical squib charges detonating inches from Chow Yun-fat's face. The opticals are clean, the pacing snaps, and the sound mix slaps your ear canal with uncompressed shotgun blasts. Your modern digital shootouts look like plastic cartoons compared to this 35mm madness. Skip the awful compressed streams; buy the Criterion or Japanese LaserDisc if you care about dynamic range.”

from “If you dug Never Surrender, here are 9 hard-hitting movies with real stunts.” →
The Long Goodbye

“Vilmos Zsigmond flashed the 35mm color negative on this one, milkying up the shadows so late-period Hollywood looks completely baked in smog and salt air. Altman kept the Panaflex camera drifting on a zoom, never cutting where you expect. You run this off a proper theatrical print and you can feel the silver grain breathing in the frame. Try streaming it and the modern digital compression algorithms turn all those sun-faded shadow gradations into pure blocky mush.”

from “9 gritty neo-noir films that actually understand shadow and film stock” →
Spider-Man: Brand New Day

“This summer's release strips Peter Parker down to sidewalk asphalt after all the multiverse clutter. Forgotten by his friends, he is pounding the pavement full-time, undergoing an internal change while hunting an invisible threat across the city. You get a desperate, solitary street hero up against something unseen. It demands disciplined sound design over giant green screens. Grab the 4K disc instead of streaming so those dark urban alleys do not dissolve into smeared macroblocking.”

from “Dug Spider-Man: Brand New Day? 6 street-level hero films with real craft.” →
The Wages of Fear

“Clouzot knew how to punish an audience. Two trucks loaded with leaking nitroglycerin, navigating washboard dirt roads in South America. You can feel the heat baking the 35mm emulsion. Armand Thirard’s high-contrast photography captures every bead of sweat and grease-stained pore without flattering anyone. The sound design is pure terror—just sputtering diesel engines and creaking floorboards waiting to vaporize. Put your digital color grading away; this is monochrome dread pulled through a projector gate at maximum tension.”

from “Into The Weight? 6 heavy, sweat-soaked thrillers built on real film stock” →

Keeps coming back toThe titles this critic picks most often

Seconds ×66 Seconds 1966 Come and See ×58 Come and See 1985 Possession ×55 Possession 1981 The Vanishing ×54 The Vanishing 1988 The Cremator ×43 The Cremator 1969 Harold and Maude ×36 Harold and Maude 1971 Wake in Fright ×33 Wake in Fright 1971 Picnic at Hanging Rock ×32 Picnic at Hanging Rock 1975

Latest lists239 in total

If you loved Dune: Part Three, these 6 massive epics put real dirt on film. If you dug Never Surrender, here are 9 hard-hitting movies with real stunts. 9 gritty neo-noir films that actually understand shadow and film stock Dug Spider-Man: Brand New Day? 6 street-level hero films with real craft. Loved Wicker? Here are 9 tactile folk fables built with real grit and craft. Dig The Cycle? Here are 5 loop thrillers cut with real discipline. Into The Weight? 6 heavy, sweat-soaked thrillers built on real film stock Dig Resident Evil? 5 Grimy Bio-Horror Flicks With Real Practical Grit Loved Digger? 9 Gritty Mud-and-Blood Thrillers Shot the Hard Way Loved Bad Apples? 8 classroom thrillers that cut right to the bone. 6 lean thrillers on real film stock that put modern streaming mush to shame 7 Time Loop Movies Where Every Splice Counts and Nothing Drags
All 239 lists

The rest of the Movies desk

The Lore ArchitectThe Vibe DetectorThe Skip Button