Hold Up, Wait A Minute: 10 Games That'll Baffle You Like *That* Off-Screen Comment

By: The Meta-Economist | 2025-12-07
Intellectual Puzzle Mystery Narrative Mind-Bending
Hold Up, Wait A Minute: 10 Games That'll Baffle You Like *That* Off-Screen Comment
Outer Wilds

1. Outer Wilds

Yo, Outer Wilds is just built different, seriously. You're in this tiny solar system, and every 22 minutes, BOOM, the sun explodes. But you gotta use that loop to figure out what's even going on. It’s not about getting stronger, it’s about knowledge. Like, every piece of info you find just clicks into place, and then you have that 'OH MY GOD' moment. It's wild how it all connects. Definitely a game that sticks with you long after you're done.
Undertale

2. Undertale

Okay, so Undertale? It legit redefines how you even think about RPGs. Every single choice you make, from sparing monsters to, well, not sparing them, comes back to hit you in the feels. And the game *knows* you're playing, like it’s aware of your resets and stuff. The characters are iconic, and the story goes places you absolutely do not expect. It’s got that indie charm but also just punches you with its narrative genius.
Portal 2

3. Portal 2

Portal 2 is just peak gaming, for real. The portal mechanics are genius, obviously, but the writing? Chef’s kiss. GLaDOS and Wheatley's banter is legendary, and the puzzles get so ridiculously complex but in the best way possible. You're constantly thinking, "Wait, how do I even...?" and then it just clicks. It’s got laughs, unexpected narrative shifts, and that co-op mode is a whole other level of brain-bending fun with a friend.
Disco Elysium

4. Disco Elysium

Yo, Disco Elysium is like, if your brain was an RPG and also a detective. You wake up with amnesia, no clue who you are, and your skills are literally parts of your psyche talking to you. The dialogue is absolutely next-level, and your choices, even subtle ones, completely shift the narrative. It's super heavy, super deep, and just makes you think about everything. Definitely not a chill game, but it's a masterpiece that messes with your head in the best way.
Return Of The Obra Dinn

5. Return Of The Obra Dinn

Obra Dinn is a flex in game design, period. You're an insurance investigator on this ghost ship, and you gotta figure out how everyone died – and their identity. The monochrome art style is iconic, but the real mind-bender is piecing together the narrative from these tiny, fragmented moments. It's pure deduction, super satisfying when you get it right, and will have you staring at a blank page for ages before that 'AHA!' moment hits.
Baba Is You

6. Baba Is You

Baba Is You is the kind of game that makes you question the very concept of rules. You're literally pushing words around on the screen to change how the game works. "BABA IS YOU," "ROCK IS PUSH," "WALL IS STOP." It's so deceptively simple at first, but then it spirals into these absolutely brain-melting puzzles. You'll feel like a genius when you solve one, only to be stumped by the next. It’s pure, unadulterated puzzle innovation.
Doki Doki Literature Club!

7. Doki Doki Literature Club!

Okay, so Doki Doki Literature Club! starts off looking like your typical, wholesome dating sim. But then, uh, it goes places. *Dark* places. It completely breaks the fourth wall and turns into something genuinely unsettling and meta-horror. You think you know what’s happening, and then the game just pulls the rug out from under you, like, five times. It’s a wild ride that’ll leave you wondering what’s even real in your own files.
Kentucky Route Zero

8. Kentucky Route Zero

Kentucky Route Zero is less a game and more an experience, honestly. It’s this incredibly atmospheric, surreal point-and-click adventure about a secret highway beneath Kentucky. The dialogue is poetic, the characters are unforgettable, and the story just washes over you in this dreamlike way. It’s super abstract, doesn't hold your hand, and makes you really think about its themes long after you've finished. Seriously trippy in the best way possible.
Her Story

9. Her Story

Her Story is like a super unique detective game where you’re just watching old police interviews on a desktop computer. You search a database using keywords, and each clip gives you tiny bits of a larger, super complex mystery. It’s totally non-linear, so you piece the narrative together yourself. You'll be scrubbing through clips, trying to catch every subtle detail. It’s brilliant, super immersive, and makes you feel like a legit detective.
INSIDE

10. INSIDE

INSIDE is just a masterclass in atmospheric storytelling without saying a single word. It’s a dark, super unsettling puzzle-platformer where you’re this kid running from something, but you don't know what. The art style is minimalist but super effective, and the puzzles are clever. But the real mind-screw is the ending, which is just... *chefs kiss*... ambiguous and totally open to interpretation. It leaves you feeling weirdly satisfied but also completely baffled.
Up Next The 12 Sonic Earthquakes That Rumbled My World (And Should Rumble Yours) →