Home/Games

8 Games So Good, They'll Make You Want to Have a Second Playthrough

8 Games So Good, They'll Make You Want to Have a Second Playthrough
ExperimentalActionAdventureSci-FiSingleplayerController
In this listDrakengard 3Fahrenheit (Indigo Prophecy)killer7Enslaved: Odyssey to the WestEternal Darkness: Sanity's RequiemPsi-Ops: The Mindgate ConspiracyVanquishBinary Domain
You've played 0 of 8 · tap “Played it” on each pick
This list contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
#1 Drakengard 3 cover

Drakengard 3

Yoko Taro’s prequel is a masterclass in narrative subversion, even if the combat often feels like a PS2 game running on a PS3. But that’s the point, isn't it? It’s deliberately clunky, a backdrop for the most unhinged, darkly comedic, and tragic story about sisters, dragons, and flower parasites you’ll ever experience. Seriously, the multiple endings don’t just offer closure; they fundamentally alter your perception of everything that came before. You'll play it again just to understand what the hell you actually witnessed.
3 critics · 10 lists →
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
#2 Fahrenheit (Indigo Prophecy) cover

Fahrenheit (Indigo Prophecy)

Before David Cage became… well, David Cage, there was Indigo Prophecy. This game, bless its ambitious heart, tried to push interactive storytelling way beyond its limits. It started as a dark, atmospheric thriller, then veered so spectacularly off the rails into bonkers sci-fi territory that you couldn't help but gape. It's a mess, but a *fascinating* mess, showcasing what happens when creators have big ideas but maybe not the best editors. You'll replay it to see if it makes any more sense the second time.
4 critics · 33 lists →
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
#3 killer7 cover

killer7

Suda51’s first big splash in the West remains an absolute trip. You’re bouncing between seven distinct personalities, each with their own bizarre traits, in a stylish, psychedelic rail-shooter that refuses to explain itself. The story is a dense, political, and philosophical enigma wrapped in a cel-shaded fever dream. Playing it again isn't just about finding secrets; it's about trying to decode the sheer artistic audacity. Few games have this much personality, or demand this much brainpower to even begin to grasp.
4 critics · 83 lists →
Play onSteam
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
#4 Enslaved: Odyssey to the West cover

Enslaved: Odyssey to the West

Ninja Theory, before they became a studio known for character action, gave us Enslaved. This game is pure heart. It’s got beautiful, post-apocalyptic visuals, a surprisingly genuine dynamic between Monkey and Trip, and combat that, while straightforward, feels impactful. What really sticks is the emotional journey and the character development. Plus, the platforming and light puzzle elements are just well-crafted. It's a genuinely charming adventure that deserved so much more recognition, and it holds up beautifully for a second pass.
4 critics · 117 lists →
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
#5 Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem cover

Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem

Oh, Eternal Darkness. Silicon Knights crafted a cosmic horror masterpiece that didn't just tell a scary story; it actively messed with *you*. The sanity effects, like corrupted save files or the game pretending to turn off your console, were revolutionary. This isn't just a psychological thriller; it's a genre-bending historical epic that constantly pulls the rug out from under you. A second playthrough reveals layers of foreshadowing and narrative brilliance you likely missed while just trying to keep your sanity meter from plummeting.
4 critics · 78 lists →
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
#6 Psi-Ops: The Mindgate Conspiracy cover

Psi-Ops: The Mindgate Conspiracy

Before every game protagonist could lift a car with their mind, there was Psi-Ops. This game just nailed the feeling of being a psychic badass. Telekinesis wasn't a gimmick; it was your main weapon, letting you ragdoll enemies, throw objects, and generally just cause glorious chaos. The physics engine was ahead of its time, making every encounter a sandbox of possibilities. It’s a pure power fantasy, and going back lets you appreciate just how well they integrated those abilities into genuinely fun, destructive gameplay.
4 critics · 23 lists →
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
#7 Vanquish cover

Vanquish

PlatinumGames at their absolute peak of pure, unadulterated action. Vanquish is a hyper-stylish, breakneck-speed cover shooter where sliding on your knees at 100 mph is the *intended* way to play. The kinetic energy, the satisfying sound design, and the sheer fluidity of movement make every firefight a ballet of destruction. Mastering the boost slide and bullet time mechanics is a reward in itself. You play this again not for the story, but for the thrill of perfecting its blisteringly fast, aggressive combat loop.
4 critics · 101 lists →
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
#8 Binary Domain cover

Binary Domain

Yakuza Studio, before they were *just* Yakuza Studio, made this ridiculously fun third-person shooter. Binary Domain had a genuinely innovative 'consequence system' where your squadmates reacted to your decisions and even voice commands. Plus, blasting robots limb by limb was incredibly satisfying. It’s got a surprisingly compelling story about what it means to be human in a future filled with hyper-realistic androids. This game was criminally overlooked, and a second playthrough really highlights its ambition and heart amidst the explosive robot action.
4 critics · 106 lists →
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
Up next These 8 Sonic Detours Will Realign Your Frequency →