Home/Games

11 Games That Made Us Scream 'You Created This Monster!'

11 Games That Made Us Scream 'You Created This Monster!'
CursedMultiplayerRPGSci-FiOpen WorldFPS
In this listCyberpunk 2077Star CitizenDiablo: ImmortalBattlefield 2042AnthemNo Man's SkyFallout 76RedfallMarvel’s AvengersThe Day BeforeOverwatch 2
You've played 0 of 11 · tap “Played it” on each pick
This list contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
#1 Cyberpunk 2077 cover

Cyberpunk 2077

Oh, Night City. The hype was a beast, and the launch? A glitch-ridden, console-breaking Frankenstein. We saw glimpses of something incredible, sure, but the reality was a broken promise, especially for those of us on older hardware. It felt like CD Projekt RED bit off way more than they could chew, then shipped it anyway, letting us pay to beta test their grand vision. A true cautionary tale of ambition versus execution.
4 critics · 72 lists →
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
#2 Star Citizen cover

Star Citizen

This one's less a game and more a perpetual Kickstarter project that occasionally lets you fly a very expensive ship. It's been in "development" for over a decade, funded by literal millions of dollars for digital jpegs of spaceships. The scope is absurd, the promises are endless, and the actual playable content remains a tech demo wrapped in a mountain of wishful thinking. You gotta wonder if it'll ever actually launch.
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
#3 Diablo: Immortal cover

Diablo: Immortal

"Do you guys not have phones?" Blizzard's infamous line perfectly encapsulated the monetization nightmare this game became. It took a beloved ARPG franchise, stripped out its soul, and replaced it with predatory microtransactions disguised as gameplay. The pay-to-win mechanics were so egregious, it felt less like playing Diablo and more like staring into the abyss of corporate greed, asking for your credit card.
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
#4 Battlefield 2042 cover

Battlefield 2042

DICE, what happened? This was supposed to be the glorious return to large-scale, chaotic warfare, but it launched a hollow shell. Missing features, terrible map design, and a general lack of polish made it feel like a budget knock-off of its predecessors. The community's frustration was palpable; we just wanted a functioning Battlefield, not this strange, half-baked imitation of a hero shooter with no identity.
2 critics · 8 lists →
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
#5 Anthem cover

Anthem

BioWare, the architects of Mass Effect and Dragon Age, stumbled hard with Anthem. Its stunning visuals couldn't hide the repetitive grind, shallow story, and endless loading screens. It felt like a game designed by committee, trying to chase the "looter shooter" trend without understanding what makes those games compelling. A gorgeous, but ultimately empty, iron man suit simulator that faded into obscurity far too quickly.
2 critics · 15 lists →
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
#6 No Man's Sky cover

No Man's Sky

Talk about a redemption arc, but its launch was a masterclass in over-promising and under-delivering. Sean Murray's infamous interviews painted a picture of infinite possibilities, only for players to discover a barren, repetitive universe. It was a stark reminder that procedurally generated content doesn't automatically equal depth or variety. The initial backlash was brutal, and rightfully so, given the blatant misrepresentation.
4 critics · 62 lists →
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
#7 Fallout 76 cover

Fallout 76

Taking a beloved single-player RPG series and turning it into a buggy, always-online survival game was a gamble that spectacularly failed at launch. From canvas bags to nuked item dupes, Bethesda seemed determined to snatch defeat from the jaws of a guaranteed success. It was a soulless, broken mess that felt like a betrayal to long-time fans who just wanted a new, quality Fallout experience.
2 critics · 19 lists →
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
#8 Redfall cover

Redfall

Arkane Studios, known for immersive sims like Dishonored and Prey, delivered a shockingly bland, uninspired co-op shooter. The signature Arkane magic was completely absent, replaced by generic open-world design and repetitive combat. It felt like a game that didn't know what it wanted to be, culminating in a critical and commercial failure that sullied the studio's reputation. A true head-scratcher.
2 critics · 9 lists →
Play onSteam
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
#9 Marvel’s Avengers cover

Marvel’s Avengers

This game had the potential to be *the* superhero team-up experience, but it crumbled under the weight of live-service expectations. Repetitive missions, a confusing loot system, and a desperate struggle to monetize every single cosmetic item drained all the fun. It became clear that Square Enix and Crystal Dynamics prioritized a treadmill economy over compelling gameplay, reducing iconic heroes to glorified action figures.
2 critics · 13 lists →
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
#10 The Day Before cover

The Day Before

This one's in a league of its own for sheer audacity. From suspicious gameplay trailers to repeated delays and eventual delisting just weeks after launch, it felt like a scam from the get-go. Promising a groundbreaking open-world zombie MMO, it delivered a barebones, broken mess that barely functioned. It wasn't just bad; it was a masterclass in how *not* to develop or market a game. A legendary disaster.
2 critics · 8 lists →
Play onSteam
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
#11 Overwatch 2 cover

Overwatch 2

Blizzard killed Overwatch 1 for this? The "sequel" felt more like a mandatory patch with a predatory battle pass system and a broken promise of PvE content. It stripped away loot boxes, only to replace them with an even more aggressive monetization scheme, while adding minimal new content. The spirit of the original was lost, replaced by a cynical cash grab that left many long-time players feeling betrayed.
3 critics · 10 lists →
Buy the game on Amazon · affiliate
Up next 8 Auditory Architectures: Pre-Digital Works That Redefined Sonic Space →