10 Shows You Totally Slept On (And Need to Stream Now)

By: The Scroll Prophet | 2026-01-20
Gritty Drama Comedy Sci-Fi Serialized Mind-Bending
10 Shows You Totally Slept On (And Need to Stream Now)
Terriers

1. Terriers

| Year: 2010 | Rating: 7.9
Seriously, how did everyone miss this? *Terriers* is peak '00s indie vibe, following two down-on-their-luck PIs in a sun-drenched, gritty San Diego. It's not about grand mysteries; it's about these messy, real guys trying to do good. The dialogue snaps, the chemistry is instant, and the pacing is this perfect, lived-in rhythm. Every episode feels like a perfectly crafted short story, but with a serialized emotional core that just hits different. It's a masterclass in character-driven storytelling, gone too soon.
Rectify

2. Rectify

| Year: 2013 | Rating: 7.6
Okay, so *Rectify* isn't a binge-rush; it's a deep, slow exhale. This show explores what happens after a man is released from death row, depicting his re-entry into a world that's moved on, and a family grappling with lingering doubts. It’s incredibly atmospheric, leaning into the quiet, often painful moments of adjustment. The storytelling is so patient, letting you sit with the characters’ internal struggles. It’s less about plot twists and more about the existential weight of freedom and memory. Absolutely haunting and beautiful.
Patriot

3. Patriot

| Year: 2018 | Rating: 1.0
Don't even try to categorize *Patriot*, it's its own thing. Imagine a spy thriller, but everyone's depressed and the humor is so dry it's practically dust. John Lakeman, our 'non-official cover' operative, just wants to play folk music, but keeps accidentally escalating international incidents. The worldbuilding is hyper-specific, with this dark, absurd logic that just works. Its pacing is deceptively slow, building up to these incredible, often tragicomic, payoffs. It's a digital-native gem that understands nuanced, character-centric narratives.
Counterpart

4. Counterpart

| Year: 2017 | Rating: 7.4
If you dig parallel universes and spy thrillers, *Counterpart* needs to be on your radar. J.K. Simmons playing two versions of the same man, navigating a Cold War between dimensions – it’s just brilliant. The show isn't just a sci-fi hook; it's a deep dive into identity, choices, and destiny. Visually, it’s sleek and moody, with a European espionage flick vibe. It understands how to build a complex world without hand-holding, making you piece together the larger conspiracy alongside the characters. So underrated.
High Maintenance

5. High Maintenance

| Year: 2016 | Rating: 6.8
This show, originally a Vimeo web series, is the ultimate New York slice-of-life anthology. It follows 'The Guy,' a weed dealer, as he cycles through different clients, giving us intimate, fleeting glimpses into their incredibly varied lives. Each episode is a mini-narrative masterpiece, perfectly paced for a digital-first audience. It's funny, poignant, and often just really chill. It's a masterclass in showing, not telling, revealing so much about urban existence through these small, perfectly observed moments. Totally unique structure.
The OA

6. The OA

| Year: 2016 | Rating: 7.5
Okay, *The OA* is pure, unfiltered surrealism and narrative audacity. It starts with a blind woman returning after seven years, now able to see, claiming to be from another dimension. This show just *goes* for it with its mythology and emotional depth. The storytelling is so unconventional, demanding your full attention as it builds its hyper-stylized world. And that ending? Absolute genius in platform-optimized cliffhangers. It’s a serialized mystery that truly committed to its unique vision, even if it ended too soon.
Mr. Robot

7. Mr. Robot

| Year: 2015 | Rating: 8.3
You probably heard of *Mr. Robot*, but did you *really* watch it? This isn't just a hacker show; it's a psychological thriller wrapped in a critique of modern society, with some of the most innovative cinematography ever. Rami Malek's performance is iconic, carrying the weight of this deeply paranoid, alienated world. The show’s rapid-fire narrative and visual language are totally digital-native, pulling you into Elliot's fragmented reality. It’s intense, intelligent, and feels more relevant now than ever. A true masterpiece of its era.
Ramy

8. Ramy

| Year: 2019 | Rating: 7.3
*Ramy* is such a fresh take on the coming-of-age story, following a first-generation Egyptian-American Muslim trying to figure out his faith, family, and identity in New Jersey. Ramy Youssef's comedic timing is perfect, but the show isn't afraid to get seriously introspective and even uncomfortable. It's a prime example of a show that knows its audience, using cultural specificity to explore universal themes of belonging and self-discovery. The pacing feels natural, like you're just hanging out with Ramy, watching him stumble through life.
Undone

9. Undone

| Year: 2019 | Rating: 7.7
This show is a visual trip, using rotoscope animation to tell a deeply philosophical story about reality, mental health, and family trauma. After a car accident, Alma starts seeing her deceased father, who tells her she can manipulate time. The animation isn't just a gimmick; it completely enhances the dreamlike, fluid narrative. It’s totally mind-bending and emotional, playing with non-linear storytelling in a way only animation can. The serialized mystery and character development are top-tier, making it a truly unique viewing experience.
Atlanta

10. Atlanta

| Year: 2016 | Rating: 8.0
Okay, *Atlanta* isn't 'slept on' for everyone, but if you haven't binged it, you're missing out on peak genre-bending television. Donald Glover's vision is just *different*. It's a comedy, a drama, a surrealist nightmare, a social commentary – sometimes all in one episode. The episodic structure allows for insane creativity, dropping you into these hyper-stylized, often uncomfortable, situations. It’s a masterclass in tone and narrative experimentation, perfectly reflecting the chaotic energy of its setting and characters. Seriously, just watch it.
Up Next Forget the Hype, These 11 Games Are the REAL GOATS You Missed! →